I have been fortunate in my seventeen plus years as a mother to four relatively healthy kids–minus food allergies, a bout or two with iron deficiency, and broken bones– to engage with many pediatricians who have been terrific.
I love pediatricians, I really do.
As a dietitian, though, I have heard from clients and friends about nutrition advice from doctors and other healthcare providers that don’t make sense in today’s world.
It’s nutrition advice that may be outdated, or even harmful–and sometimes useless.
Pediatricians get little education in medical school on the topic of nutrition.
Yet, pediatricians are the frontline for childhood nutrition advice.
I would love to see pediatricians get more nutrition education in medical school, but I am glad there is a wonderful resource in Fearless Feeding: How to Raise Healthy Eaters from High Chair to High School (shameless plug) for them. Hint, hint: this is a GREAT holiday gift for your doctor!
8 Pieces of Unhelpful Nutrition Advice
I would love to stop hearing this advice!
For Picky Eating
“Let them go hungry. No child has ever starved themselves.”
Maybe, but there are some kids who will not eat. They will go to bed hungry, or go days without eating.
These kids often have a more significant form of picky eating and need more professional help and investigation.
With the higher rates of premature birth, more and more children are having difficulties with eating.
A pat answer like the one above only further frustrates the parent, may endanger the child, and doesn’t help kids get the services they may need.
“It’s normal, you just have to wait it out.”
Yes, picky eating may be a normal stage of child development. By the time kids enter elementary school, picky eating should be on its way out, and signs of food variety, adventurousness and pleasure with eating should be apparent.
Sure, all kids have the right to dislike certain foods, but they shouldn’t be avoiding groups of foods, like vegetables, at this point.
School-age picky eating is a sign that there may be more to the story such as sensory integration disorder, learned behavior, a medical condition or a combination of these.
For Overweight Children
“Don’t worry, she’ll grow out of it.”
Today, most children who are classified as overweight or obese (a BMI over 85%ile and 95%ile, respectively) aren’t growing out of it. That doesn’t necessarily mean there should be dramatic action, though.
That’s to be sorted out on an individual basis.
One thing that makes it difficult for all is our food supply. It is too delicious, too calorie-dense, and too available, especially for kids.
Additionally, as a nation, we are too sedentary. It’s simply too hard to be at a healthy weight without healthy amounts of physical activity, awareness and for some, changes in lifestyle habits.
“She’ll grow out of this,” implies families don’t have to do anything–just maintain the status quo. This is an unfortunate message because many people can take small steps and work towards a healthier lifestyle.
“Just give them more fruit and vegetables.”
Yes, give them more! But this isn’t the only solution.
Please don’t imply there’s only one action to take. It’s OK to focus on one thing at a time, but let families know this is the beginning, and there will be more to come.
Then, refer them out to a nutrition professional who can see them regularly and follow them routinely.
For Eating Disorders
“She’s fine—her weight is normal.”
A teen (or child) doesn’t have to be rail thin to have an eating disorder.
In fact, it’s not uncommon for individuals with eating disorders to be normal weight or overweight, and underweight is just a portion of the population suffering from eating disorders.
Healthcare providers really need to have their eyes wide open, because as early as six years of age girls start to express concerns about their body weight and shape.
Forty to sixty percent of elementary school girls aged six to twelve are worried about becoming too fat, a concern that sticks around throughout their lifetime. These concerns are some of the most well-known precursors to the development of an eating disorder.
“This is just a stage.”
Many parents will come to the doctor with fears that their child may have an eating disorder.
I can almost guarantee that these parents have sat with these fears for some time—trying to figure it out on their own.
Parent’s concerns shouldn’t be taken lightly. Brushing off disordered eating or a potential eating disorder only allows the disorder to take root and gain momentum.
Families need help and pediatricians are the link to that help. If it is in fact, just a stage, parents will be thankfully relieved to know so for sure.
“Make sure he eats.”
Yes, healthcare providers say this, and so do Dads.
As if you could possibly force a child or teen with (or without) an eating disorder to eat!
I guess you could, but then he would find ways to lie to you, feel badly (maybe), and become more deeply entrenched in his disorder.
If eating were the solution, then it would be an easy fix.
With an average recovery rate of seven years, it’s clear that ensuring a child eats isn’t ‘the only fix’ for an eating disorder.
For Underweight Kids
“You need to fatten her up!”
Easier said than done. Many times, as you know, there are other ‘things’ going on with the underweight child, such as food allergies, picky eating, or medical conditions making it uncomfortable for the child to eat.
Then, there may also be interactions between the parent and child that are unproductive—such as pressuring the child to eat more, or punishing him for not eating the right foods, or enough of them.
My suggestion? Send that family to a nutritionist who can spend time getting to know the ins and outs of the family dynamic and work with the foods the child is willing to eat, building from there.
What nutrition advice have you heard that has made little sense, or has left you feeling frustrated?
Written by: Jill Castle, MS, RDN
Published on: December 10, 2013
Updated on: May 9, 2019